No Oysters

You may have read in the Manchester Evening News that Greater Manchester is set to get an equivalent of the “Oyster” smartcard scheme available in London. It’s a cute piece of Government spin but don’t expect a smartcard scheme any time soon.

The Government has pledged £2.2m towards the implementation of the scheme. In London, the initial contract (subsequently torn up) was for a minimum of £100m, and that was at 1998 prices. Years later, the scheme is still not available on most National Rail routes, and although I do possess an Oyster card, if I want to visit my friends in Chingford or New Eltham I have to buy a paper travelcard even now.

Although Greater Manchester is smaller, it is also much more complex, with a myriad of small bus companies, unlike London’s franchise system. The idea that £2.2m would even come close to implementing such a scheme is ludicrous – local residents will rightly see this as nothing more than a pre-election gimmick designed not to improve public transport but to grab headlines.

Smart ticketing has my full support, but let’s see a workable proposal first, rather than an inadequate bribe.

3 Responses to “No Oysters”


  1. 1 Pete

    Well, its £2.2m we weren’t going to get for a plan B that doesn’t exist…

    I expect we’ll be getting more of these token gestures from the Kremlin in the coming months as Labour try to cling power.

  2. 2 Big Davie

    You mean like the latest ‘promise’ to electrify (in effect) Preston to Blackpool/Liverpool/Manchester (http://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/s/1186040_gordon_browns_article_for_the_men)?

  3. 3 Iain

    Quite possibly!

Leave a Reply